Welcome to the blog Hitech Tips

A blog about web and IT. Sharing things I use at work.

How to Choose Between Joomla, Drupal and Wordpress

Posted by Mr.Editor Saturday, March 6, 2010

image

This post presents three summaries on how to choose between three content managers systems. These summaries provide you a quick overview but for deeper insight follow the links to the original articles.

The links for these CMS are

Enjoy and give your feedback.

1. From compassdesigns.net:

image

 

2. From goodwebpractices.com:

Wordpress Pros

  • Simple to use - No need for modifications
  • Excellent for blogging or sharing thoughts in a sequential manner
  • Even the most elderly of users can get the hang of it quickly

Wordpress Cons

  • Not developer friendly
  • The community seems to like to complain
  • Upgrades bring more bugs than fixes sometimes

 

Drupal Pros

  • Extremely developer friendly. If I loved code more I would almost always pick this system.
  • Strong community to help discern the dozens (hundreds) of functions and tags available.
  • Can be used to create some really awesome websites that can outperform a majority of other sites out there.

Drupal Cons

  • Not very designer and user-friendly. It's hard for someone with little code knowledge to make the leaps required to do the very cool things that Drupal is becoming known for.
  • Theming of Drupal has been a huge case of fail (until recently). Probably because it has been developers, not designers, that are making the themes.
  • Getting a Drupal website published could cost you more time, and thus more money, than Wordpress or Joomla.

 

Joomla Pros

  • Friendly for all types of users - Designers, Developers and Administrators
  • Huge community is awesome for assisting with creation of websites
  • Has been rapidly growing and improving itself for the past three years

Joomla Cons

  • Still not user-friendly enough for everyone to understand
  • Not quite as powerful as Drupal, and can be a bit confusing for some to jump into
  • Recently rebuilt the entire system from ground-up, and so there are still many out there sticking to the old versions (1.0.x)

From drupal.org

(yeah, it's one of three opinion's but they are realistic)

Drupal
* Rock solid & high quality platform
* Real multi-site-feature (only one installation for several sites)
* Any Kind of user groups & user permissions, OpenId compliant in Version 6
* Can run membership and community sites, not only CMS etc
* Powerful templating system. Any XHTML or CSS template can be easily converted to Drupal.
* Drupal needs a little time investment to realize all the huge possibilities of Drupal
* Clear, high quality code and API (easy to integrate with other solutions etc)
* Flexibility and no known limitations
* Many high profile sites use Drupal (e.g.: MTV UK, BBC, the Onion, Nasa, Greenpeace UK, New york observer. )

Joomla
* If you are not techy its good to start
* Easy install & setup with your mouse
* Easy learning curve
* Cannot integrate other scripts etc. to your site
* Generally you cannot create high-end sites, without investing huge amount
* No SEO out of the box, URLs are not search engine friendly.
* Server resources utilization is more compared to drupal
* Only one site per installation
* No Single Log-in to several sites
* No User groups & permissions
* More intuitive administration user interface
* Some polished modules for things like calendars, polls, etc.
* Modules cost you money

System Requirements:

* Drupal can work with MySQL and Postgres while Joomla is known to support only MySQL
* Drupal can work with Apache or IIS while Joomla is known to support only Apache
* Joomla support SSL logins and SSL pages. Drupal not known to support it.

Site Management

* Drupal has free add on for Workflow management. Joomla not known to have one.
* Drupal has inbuilt Translation manager. Joomla has a Free ad on for the same
* Drupal has more granular priviledge managment

Interoperability:

* Drupal has iCal support [Add on] , Joomla not known to have one.
* Drupal is XHTML Complaint. Joomla not known to be one.
* Drupal has excellent versioning and Audit trail which Joomla lacks


4 comments

  1. Dave Keays Says:
  2. Drupal doesn't allow SSL? Mixed-content is a problem on Drupal, but there are modules to help handle that. But I don't want to use something so insecure when SSL is needed.

     
  3. Reynold Hugh Says:
  4. This is really a nice post and I think that the popularity of drupal is increasing day by day.
    Css Templates

     
  5. John H Says:
  6. Great article. Good to have confirmation. This was a strong path I was considering for a client. The other path is Blogspot with Joomla until the following grows. BTW Joomla ROCKS. I use all three and Joomla for CMS is a great choice.

     
  7. sukumar Says:
  8. your are gave that table is wonderful really and para also nice. joomla is one of the most people are using. Joomla Web design India

     

Post a Comment

Followers